@elizabethjamieson thanks for the nice video. Yes, the crop you are getting is not the best, but Facebook typically does a smart crop to show relevant part of the headline. In this case it looks like their algorithm does not work that well.
Yes, we will definitely consider implementing an advanced, optional feature to upload a specific image at 1.91x1 aspect ratio specifically for Open Graph and Twitter Cards
I will talk to the team and give you an update.
Again, thanks for helping us improve Listly